Skip the Hotel: 11 New Jersey Bed and Breakfasts for a Cozy Staycation

Woolverton Inn in Stockton, NJ, a stone manor house with a slate mansard roof, white shutters and a red front door, with four sheep grazing on the lawn beyond a split-rail fence at sunset

Skip the Hotel: 11 New Jersey Bed and Breakfasts for a Cozy Staycation

Woolverton Inn in Stockton, NJ, a stone manor house with a slate mansard roof, white shutters and a red front door, with four sheep grazing on the lawn beyond a split-rail fence at sunset

Abby Montanez

New Jersey Digest may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. As an Amazon Associate, New Jersey Digest earns from qualifying purchases.

From a 1700s gristmill inn in Hope to restored Victorians in Cape May, these 11 stays come with perks like historic architecture, homemade breakfast, afternoon tea, and porches built for slowing down.

Sometimes traveling out of state can feel like too much effort. And while hotels are typically the preferred choice, staycationers are seeking a different type of experience—more residential comforts, if you will. Lucky for us, New Jersey has its fair share of bed and breakfasts, spanning from north to south.

For me, a good B&B embodies the unique charm and coziness of home. Often, your stay comes with special touches from the host. Along with a relaxed feeling, picture freshly baked muffins for you delivered every morning. You can consider this list a beginner’s guide to New Jersey bed and breakfasts right now.

Woolverton Inn – Stockton

This elegant property sits right on the New Jersey-Pennsylvania border. Better known as a popular wedding venue, Woolverton Inn also makes for a great romantic getaway, thanks to its bucolic setting. This charming manor-turned-bed-and-breakfast offers guests a chance to rest their heads in either the main house or The Cottages. Begin the day with a hearty three-course country breakfast before exploring the surrounding area’s historic splendor.

Photo via @woolvertoninn

The Inn at Millrace Pond – Hope

Head to the scenic countryside of North Jersey and unpack your bags at The Inn at Millrace Pond. This B&B has a rustic feel—think a gristmill and stone structures—and dates back to the 1700s. The 23-acre property boasts 17 renovated rooms with private baths, a main dining room, an on-site tavern and meeting house. If you don’t want to meander too far from the grounds, you’ll find picturesque pathways and even a wooden footbridge.

Whistling Swan Inn – Stanhope

The opulent Whistling Swan Inn melds a modern getaway with the grandeur of the Victorian era. Think deep-hued furniture and lots of ornate finishings. This B&B is close to many New Jersey attractions, including Waterloo Village, Lake Hopatcong, state parks and more. When you return from a busy day, unwind in the side-porch hammock or get cozy for the night around the fireplace with homemade chocolate chip cookies. Breakfast here is served buffet style and is best enjoyed overlooking the English garden.

Photo via @whistling_swan_inn

The Neighbour House B&B – Long Valley

Sitting outside in the early mornings on the columned porch of The Neighbour House B&B is a luxury in its own right. This 1800s farmhouse combines Greek Revival architecture with a rural, homey vibe. Guests have access to a large living room, a dining room and a reading room in addition to the kitchen. The warm and welcoming guest rooms are located on the second floor. Among the many amenities, guests are served a full country breakfast—a generous display of fresh fruit, yogurt, cereal, eggs and homemade baked goods.

The Ampersand Inn – Newton

This secluded (albeit wildlife-abundant) oasis is a welcome respite from the bustling tri-state area. The Ampersand Inn, formerly the Wooden Duck B&B, is situated among the woods of Sussex County and offers 10 guest rooms divided between the Estate House and the Carriage House. The grounds include an in-ground pool (open seasonally), gardens and an outdoor patio, while inside you’ll find a dining room and a den. A three-course breakfast is served every morning and features seasonal offerings from local farms and butchers.

The Hugh – Cape May

Take one French Second Empire house and two ex-fashion-industry professionals with an eye for food, style and design, and you get The Hugh. The boutique B&B officially opened in summer 2020. The Hugh’s interiors are super-chic—what owners John and Sandy Vizzone describe as “modern Victorian.” Local walks around the lovely Cape May area are encouraged, and breakfast is prepared daily by Sandy using sustainable local ingredients. There’s also an on-site French bistro, Maison Bleu.

Photo via @the_hugh_inn

The Gables – Beach Haven

The charming seaside town of Beach Haven is the perfect setting for The Gables. This historic inn-meets-restaurant is a well-known spot for Jersey Shore travelers. The inn has five romantic guest rooms outfitted with marble bathrooms, antique accessories, spa tubs and more. Dining at the on-site restaurant is a must. It’s open every weekend during the fall and spring. All stays come with a complimentary gourmet breakfast.

The Queen Victoria – Cape May

The Queen Victoria consistently finds itself among the “best” bed and breakfasts in New Jersey. This award-winning B&B is just blocks from Cape May’s beaches, shops and other local attractions. There are four restored buildings that offer accommodations, and each boasts beautiful, distinct period features. Picture cozy parlor spaces, porches and fireplaces. A generous homemade breakfast buffet is served daily, featuring recipes from “The Queen Victoria Cookbook.” Afternoon tea is also available. 

Visiting for the holidays? The Queen Victoria joins the festive fun during Cape May’s Victorian Christmas—here’s how to make the most of it.

Angel of the Sea – Cape May

Angel of the Sea is located in Cape May’s East End and features 27 Victorian-style guest rooms. It was originally built around 1850 and later turned into a B&B in 1989. With a wraparound porch and elaborate gingerbread detailing, Angel of the Sea is a nod to Cape May’s past. You’ll love the little details like afternoon tea with freshly baked sweets or wine and cheese in the evening. Complimentary beach chairs, umbrellas, bicycles and more also help to elevate the experience.

The Jonathan Pitney House – Absecon

Back in the 1800s, “The Father of Atlantic City” saw the potential of the Absecon area. The Jonathan Pitney House still stands in idyllic Absecon, where fresh sea air and saltwater permeate the area. Inside this New Jersey B&B, guests will find original materials, from its fireplaces to its clawfoot tubs. The accommodations include a range of stately guest rooms and luxurious suites. Take a day trip to nearby Renault Winery or head to Historic Smithville.

Photoa via @jonathanpitneyhouse

Ocean Park Inn – Ocean Grove

There’s tons of character packed into this 13-room boutique B&B. The exterior features a super-cute porch and lots of hanging greenery to match its facade. The interiors are elevated by thoughtful touches, from indulgent (complimentary) breakfasts to ocean views. Ocean Park Inn is also located blocks from Asbury Park and Ocean Grove’s Main Avenue.

Abby is The Digest's Managing Editor. She spends her time looking at dogs on Instagram and eating her way around Jersey City.