Locked vs Unlocked iPhone: Which Should You Buy in 2025?

Locked vs Unlocked iPhone: Which Should You Buy in 2025?

Staff

The difference between locked and unlocked iPhones can cost you hundreds of dollars and create major headaches when you want to switch carriers. Most people focus solely on the upfront price without considering the long-term costs, including carrier restrictions, limited resale value, and expensive roaming charges, when traveling.

Locked iPhones are compatible only with specific carriers, such as Verizon, AT&T, or T-Mobile, while unlocked iPhones can be used with any carrier that supports the phone’s technology. This difference affects everything from your monthly bill flexibility to how much you can sell your phone for later.

Understanding which option makes financial sense requires looking beyond the initial purchase price to consider total ownership costs, your usage patterns, and plans for switching carriers or traveling internationally.

5 Key Differences You Need to Know

  1. Carrier restrictions – Locked phones only work with one carrier
  2. Purchase pricing – Locked phones often cost less upfront
  3. Monthly plan flexibility – Unlocked phones let you switch carriers anytime
  4. Resale value – Unlocked iPhones sell for 10-20% more
  5. International use – Unlocked phones work with foreign SIM cards

Locked iPhone: Pros and Cons

Why Carriers Offer Locked iPhones (The Financial Hook)

Carriers lock iPhones to keep you as a customer long enough to recoup the money they lose by selling phones at a loss. When Verizon sells you an iPhone for $200 less than Apple’s price, they’re betting you’ll stay with them long enough to make up that loss through monthly service fees.

This business model works because most people hate switching carriers. Carriers rely on customer inertia and the hassle of changing phone numbers, transferring data, and navigating new billing systems to keep you locked in, extending beyond just the phone restrictions.

Benefits of Buying a Locked iPhone from Carriers

Locked iPhones cost less upfront because carriers subsidize the purchase price. You might pay $699 for an iPhone that costs $899 unlocked from Apple. Carriers also offer payment plans that spread the cost over 24-36 months with 0% interest, making expensive phones more affordable.

Customer service can be simplified with locked phones, as you have a single point of contact for both device and service issues. If your phone breaks or you have network problems, you deal with one company instead of coordinating between a phone seller and a service provider.

Trade-in programs from carriers often offer competitive values for upgrading to newer models, especially if you’re staying within their ecosystem of devices and services.

Hidden Costs and Restrictions You Need to Know

Locked phones trap you into specific carrier plans that might not offer the best value. You can’t take advantage of cheaper MVNOs (mobile virtual network operators) or switch to better deals from competing carriers without unlocking your phone first.

Early termination fees can range from $200 to $ 350 if you choose to leave before your contract ends. Even if you pay off your phone early, you may still face unlocking restrictions or waiting periods before your carrier will unlock your device.

International roaming charges with locked phones can be costly. Carriers charge $10-$ 15 per day for global data, while an unlocked phone allows you to purchase local SIM cards for a fraction of that cost.

Unlocked iPhone: Complete Freedom Explained

What “Unlocked” Really Means for Your iPhone

An unlocked iPhone has no software restrictions tying it to a specific carrier. You can insert any compatible SIM card and use the phone immediately, whether it’s from Verizon, T-Mobile, AT&T, or smaller carriers like Mint Mobile or Cricket.

This freedom extends beyond just switching carriers – you can also use multiple phone numbers with different SIM cards, switch between work and personal lines, or use local carriers when traveling internationally.

For businesses purchasing wholesale iPhones for employees, unlocked phones offer maximum flexibility for various carrier relationships and international operations.

Advantages of Buying Unlocked iPhones

Unlocked iPhones give you complete control over your wireless costs. You can switch to a cheaper carrier at any time, take advantage of promotional deals, or use prepaid plans without carrier approval or unlocking delays.

International travel has become much cheaper and more convenient. Instead of paying $10-15 per day for carrier roaming, you can buy local SIM cards for $10-20 that provide full data and calling for the entire trip.

Your unlocked iPhone will work with any carrier’s network technology, whether GSM (AT&T, T-Mobile) or CDMA (Verizon, Sprint legacy). This compatibility makes unlocked phones easier to sell and more valuable in the secondary market.

When Unlocked iPhones Cost More (And Why It’s Worth It)

Unlocked iPhones cost $50-200 more upfront because you’re paying the full retail price without carrier subsidies. However, this higher upfront cost often pays for itself through lower monthly bills and better resale values.

You’ll need to pay the full amount upfront or arrange your own financing, unlike carrier payment plans. Some retailers offer financing options for unlocked phones, but the terms may not be as favorable as those offered by carriers.

The extra cost becomes worthwhile if you switch carriers frequently, travel internationally, or want the flexibility to shop for the best wireless deals without being tied to a specific phone.

Cost Comparison: Locked vs Unlocked iPhone Ownership

Real-World Price Analysis Over 2 Years

Let’s compare the total cost of owning an iPhone 15 for two years:

Locked iPhone Scenario:

  • Phone cost: $699 (with carrier subsidy)
  • Monthly service: $80 x 24 months = $1,920
  • Early termination fee (if switching): $250
  • Total: $2,869

Unlocked iPhone Scenario:

  • Phone cost: $899 (full retail price)
  • Monthly service: $60 x 24 months = $1,440 (cheaper MVNO)
  • No termination fees
  • Total: $2,339

The unlocked iPhone saves $530 over two years despite the higher upfront cost, mainly through cheaper monthly service options.

Resale Value Differences (Unlocked vs Locked)

Unlocked iPhones consistently sell for 10-20% more than locked versions because they appeal to a broader range of buyers. A locked Verizon iPhone can only be sold to Verizon customers, whereas an unlocked iPhone works with any carrier.

After 18 months, an unlocked iPhone 14 might sell for $650 while the same locked version sells for $550. This $100 difference adds to the total cost savings of buying unlocked from the start. Retailers specializing in wholesale phones often prefer to have unlocked inventory because it moves more quickly and appeals to a broader range of customers across different carrier networks.

International Travel and Roaming Cost Savings

International roaming with locked phones costs $10-15 per day through major carriers. A two-week international trip costs $140-210 just for basic data access.

With an unlocked iPhone, you can purchase local SIM cards for $10-$ 30 that provide unlimited data for the entire trip. Some international SIM cards are compatible across multiple countries, offering even better value for multi-country travel.

Business travelers and frequent international visitors can save hundreds of dollars annually by using unlocked phones with local or global SIM cards instead of paying carrier roaming fees.

How to Tell if Your iPhone is Locked + Unlocking Options

  1. Simple Ways to Check if Your iPhone is Locked or Unlocked

The easiest way to check is to insert a SIM card from a different carrier. If your iPhone connects to the new network and makes calls, it’s unlocked. If you get “Invalid SIM” or “SIM Not Supported” messages, your phone is locked.

You can also check in Settings > General > About > Carrier Lock. If it shows “No SIM restrictions,” your iPhone is unlocked. If it shows a carrier name, your phone is locked to that specific carrier.

Contact your carrier and inquire about the lock status of your phone. They can tell you immediately whether your phone is locked and what requirements you need to meet to unlock it.

3. Carrier Unlock Process: What You Need to Know

Most carriers will unlock your iPhone if you meet their requirements, typically by paying off your phone balance and completing any minimum service period (usually 40-60 days). Military personnel can often get phones unlocked immediately with proper documentation.

The unlock process involves submitting a request through your carrier’s website or customer service. Processing takes 1-5 business days for most carriers. Once approved, you’ll receive instructions on how to complete the unlock, which typically involves connecting to iTunes or updating your phone.

Verizon automatically unlocks phones 60 days after the purchase date. T-Mobile and AT&T require unlock requests, but process them quickly for qualified accounts.

Should You Buy Locked or Unlocked? (Decision Guide)

Choose locked iPhones if you’re happy with your current carrier, want lower upfront costs, and don’t travel internationally frequently. Locked phones make sense if you plan to stay with the same carrier for two years or more and value the convenience of carrier customer service.

Choose unlocked iPhones if you want carrier flexibility, travel internationally, or prefer shopping for the best wireless deals. Unlocked phones are ideal for individuals who frequently switch carriers or want to use their phones with multiple carriers for both work and personal use.

For businesses or retailers, unlocked phones provide maximum flexibility and better resale values, making them the preferred choice despite higher upfront costs.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can I unlock my iPhone myself without going through my carrier? Avoid third-party unlocking services that claim to unlock phones without carrier approval. These services often don’t work permanently and can void your warranty. The only reliable way to unlock an iPhone is through your carrier’s official process.
  2. Do unlocked iPhones work with all carriers? Unlocked iPhones are compatible with all major US carriers, but it’s recommended to verify network compatibility. Older iPhones may not support all of a carrier’s frequency bands, which can potentially affect data speeds or coverage in certain areas.

Will unlocking my iPhone void the warranty? No, carrier unlocking through official channels doesn’t void your Apple warranty. Only jailbreaking or using unauthorized modification software can affect warranty coverage. Official carrier unlocks are entirely safe and reversible.

The New Jersey Digest is a new jersey magazine that has chronicled daily life in the Garden State for over 10 years.