If you’re in New Jersey and looking to cast a line, maybe even land that trophy fish you can brag about for years –  well, guess what? The Garden State isn’t just about jughandles, Taylor ham, or pork rolls – it’s also home to some pretty amazing fishing spots. From the salty shores of the Atlantic to the freshwater lakes tucked away inland, New Jersey keeps you hooked. 

Wondering if this guide is for beginners or pros? We’d say both.

Moving forward, let’s talk about Spruce Run Reservoir fishing. This place is the real deal for freshwater fishing. If you haven’t heard of it, don’t worry – you’re about to get the lowdown.

1. Spruce Run Reservoir Fishing: The Freshwater Jackpot

First up on our list is Spruce Run Reservoir, a massive 1,290-acre gem located up in Clinton, north-central Jersey. For those of you who think New Jersey is just highways and malls, it’s not. It is a peaceful reservoir surrounded by greenery, with plenty of room to cast out and let your worries drift away (along with the occasional lure).

Spruce Run Reservoir fishing isn’t just about hanging out with a cold drink and a bucket of worms. Oh no, it’s a freshwater paradise where you can land everything from smallmouth bass to trout and even northern pike. 

Fun fact: In March and April, anglers get all giddy when those big ol’ pike; some weighing up to 10 pounds – make their way towards the creeks like they’re late for a very important fishy meeting.

But don’t just bring any old gear; bring your “A-game.” You’ll want something sturdy because Spruce Run fishing is not for the faint of heart. When that pike hits, it’s like your rod has suddenly turned into a live wire. Oh, and if you’re into crappie fishing, this spot is your jam too. 

Crappies here can get pretty hefty, and let’s be real – who doesn’t want to show off a two-pound crappie? 

Now that I’ve got you all fired up about Spruce Run Reservoir fishing, let’s dive into some insider tips. First off, if you’re after the big fish, head over to the mouths of Spruce Run Creek or Mulhockaway Creek. 

These spots are where the fish hang out like they’re at some underwater VIP lounge. In the cooler months, especially early spring, you’ll find those pikes lurking around. And hey, even the trout like to make an appearance, especially the elusive brown trout that somehow manages to survive in the warm waters. 

Fishing from the shore can be effective, but if you have access to a kayak or a canoe, that’s even better. Electric motors are allowed, and they help you glide across the water, but keep in mind there’s a horsepower limit. No zipping around like you’re in a speedboat commercial. You’re there to fish, after all!

2. Barnegat Bay: Coastal Charm

Now, let’s talk about saltwater. If you’re into surfcasting or just want to feel that cool ocean breeze, head to Barnegat Bay. This bay stretches across 42 miles of New Jersey’s coastline, and it’s an absolute dream for anglers. Whether you’re casting from the shore, wading into the shallows, or hopping on a boat, Barnegat Bay has it all – fluke, striped bass, bluefish, you name it.

The real magic here happens when the tide is right, and you get that perfect combination of current and baitfish. This isn’t one of those places where you sit around wondering if you’re going to catch anything. No, Barnegat Bay’s ecosystem is teeming with fish. You’ve got tidal flats, river mouths, and inlets, all perfect for fishing.

If you’re lucky, you might just hook into a keeper striped bass or a fat fluke. And let’s not forget bluefish; these bad boys fight like they’ve got a grudge against you personally. Pro tip: if you’re new to surfcasting, stop by one of the local tackle shops first and ask what the fish are biting. It’s usually a bunker or squid, but it never hurts to check.

3. Lake Hopatcong: The Big Pond That Could

Next on our list is Lake Hopatcong, New Jersey’s largest freshwater lake. If you’re into boating and fishing, this is your spot. This lake has some serious variety, from largemouth bass to walleye and muskies. Yes, muskies. These fish are basically underwater torpedoes with teeth, and catching one is like winning the fishing lottery.

Spring and fall are prime times for Lake Hopatcong fishing, but the summer months are good for night fishing if you can handle the mosquitos. And here’s a little secret: if you want to up your chances of landing a big one, head to the weed lines or the deeper drop-offs where the bigger fish tend to lurk. Just be patient – those monsters don’t come easy.

4. Delaware River: Go With the Flow

For a mix of freshwater adventure and some scenic views, you’ve got to try the Delaware River. This river is massive, and it’s one of those places where you can really get away from the crowds. Whether you’re wading in or fishing from a canoe, the Delaware is home to smallmouth bass, shad, and even the occasional walleye.

The best part? You can fish different stretches of the river depending on what you’re after. Up in the northern parts, you’ll find colder waters with trout, while the southern stretches near Philly are great for bass and catfish. It’s like a choose-your-own-adventure book, but with fish.

5. Sandy Hook: Saltwater Heaven – A Wild Card Option

Last but not least, we’ve got Sandy Hook, where the Atlantic Ocean meets Raritan Bay. This spot is a magnet for striped bass, bluefish, and fluke, and it also has killer views of the NYC skyline. Who doesn’t want to fish with a backdrop like that?

The best time to fish in Sandy Hook is during the spring and fall migrations when the fish are moving through. You can fish from the beach or jetty or even get on a charter boat. And if you’re feeling extra adventurous, try fishing at night during the summer; it’s an experience.

Conclusion

And that’s about it! New Jersey’s top fishing spots, from the inland calm of Spruce Run Reservoir to the salty shores of Barnegat Bay and beyond. Know that if you’re looking for a peaceful day on a lake or the thrill of fighting a monster-striped bass, New Jersey will surprise you in the best way possible, no matter what kind of angler you are!