A New Milk N Cookies Location Set To Open in Montclair, NJ

by Laura DeSiena

The streets of downtown Montclair just got a whole lot sweeter! The NY-based cookie chain Milk N Cookies is stepping onto the scene with a new location set to open on 43 Church Street in Montclair, NJ. The popular dessert shop boasts a unique menu of delectable infused cookies, milkshakes, and fresh ice cream treats. Alongside these one-of-a-kind items is a family-friendly atmosphere catering to visitors of all ages, who can enjoy either a basic dessert combination or have their more extravagant taste buds met with exciting new flavor options. Let’s take a look at what makes these treats so unique and how you can get your hands on these sugary slices of heaven.    

The Many Locations

Milk N Cookies was founded in 2018 by a duo of friends who desired to combine their passion for sweets and sugary breakfast treats to create a unique dessert hang-out spot for all ages to enjoy. Their vision for the company was to bring together friends and family in a unique way, all while enjoying some treats with a creative twist. When searching for the perfect location, they landed in the family-oriented town of Mamaroneck, NY which was vacant of such an eatery. 

They aimed to make the shop a warm, welcoming atmosphere for locals to bring family and friends to socialize with flat-screen TVs, plenty of seating, and even private event space. Due to the success of Mamaroneck, two additional locations opened up. One at the Willowbrook Mall in Wayne, NJ, and the other at 163 Bedford Street in Stamford, CT.  However, the company plans to further expand its sweet tooth reach in the next few years.  

When visiting Milk N Cookies, guests are met with a sleek black and white interior, allowing for the spotlight to focus on the colorful cereal lining the glass-cased cookie bar. As guests line up to try the newest flavor combination, their eyes are met with various sheets of freshly made cookies quickly being brought out of the oven from behind the counter. 

Whether you have young children or are an older adult yourself, Milk N Cookies has something for you. Guests of any age are encouraged to tap into their inner child when making selections. This embrace of juvenility has become the backbone of their business model.

“We have teenagers, 20 to 30-year-olds, young families with little kids, and older people who come in because it doesn’t matter how old you are…your inner child is there,” George Spirou, co-owner of the Stamford location shared in an interview with News 12. “You are never going to outgrow that child inside of you.”

A Menu of Sweet Indulgence 

This dessert shop offers more than just your typical milk and cookie combination. The menu boasts a mouth-watering variety of unique treats, including massive stuffed cookies and cereal-infused milkshakes and ice cream. As the official vendor of Duchess Cookies, Milk N Cookies’ front cookie bar is decked out with several diverse flavor offerings such as the Cookie Monster, Oreo Cheesecake, Galaxy, Red Velvet, and many more. Each cookie is uniquely stuffed and topped with colorful designs and flavors, with creations like the Unicorn Cheesecake Sugar Cookie featuring pink and purple shades oozing alongside a luscious strawberry cheesecake filling, and a dusting of edible glitter. The most popular cookie order is the Cookie Monster, a blue sugar cookie wrapped around a gooey chocolate chip cookie center. 


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Milk N Cookies ®️ (@milkncookies)

If the idea of cereal mixed in with your delectable treat excites you, look no further than the many cereal treat options Milk N Cookies has to offer. Guests are invited to fuse their creamy milkshake or ice cream cone with a large selection of childhood cereal hits such as Fruity Pebbles, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, and Trix, to name a few. The 15 sugary flavors displayed on the shop’s wall invite guests to build enticing combinations like the featured Trix-infused vanilla ice cream garnished with Trix cereal, Teddy Grahams, and raspberry syrup. 

If these fun combinations aren’t your thing, you can skip the drama and have a satisfying bowl of cereal and milk as if you were in the comfort of your own home instead. Whatever blend you choose, you can be sure the craving to have your morning cereal paired with ice cream since you were a young child can now be enjoyed without a parent’s permission. 


View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Milk N Cookies ®️ (@milkncookies)

While there is no official opening day announced quite yet, be sure to visit their official website here for any new announcements regarding the Montclair location. Although the full menu is not available online, their cookie offerings are available for a sneak peek via their Instagram or Shop tab on their website. To get your fix before the grand opening, plan a trip to the other New Jersey location stationed inside the Willowbrook Mall of Wayne, NJ—right near the food court. 

About the Author/s

All posts

Laura DeSiena is a certified Jersey Girl with a passion for music, playing the guitar, and binge-watching 90’s sitcoms. As an aspiring writer and author, she hopes to publish a book someday. When she’s not writing, you can usually find her browsing the shelves of Barnes & Noble in search of her next read.

Related Articles

Leave a Comment

Yes, I would like to receive emails from The Digest Online. Sign me up!

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: New Jersey Digest. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact