A federal judge issued a partial decision Monday in the legal battle between New York and New Jersey over the NYC congestion pricing plan, leaving its January 5 launch uncertain.
The ruling dismissed most of New Jersey’s objections but directed federal officials to provide more information on environmental impacts, particularly air quality issues affecting New Jersey communities.
New York officials welcomed the decision, asserting the program can proceed. “The program will move forward this weekend,” said Governor Kathy Hochul. MTA Chair Janno Lieber called the ruling a validation, stating it “rejected New Jersey’s claim that the Environmental Assessment was flawed.”
New Jersey’s attorney Randy Mastro argued otherwise, claiming the remand effectively halts the program. “The MTA cannot move forward with its current proposal,” he said.
Will NYC Congestion Pricing Start January 5?
Set to begin Sunday, January 5, the program would charge drivers $9 during peak hours to enter Manhattan below 60th Street. Critics in New Jersey, including Congressman Josh Gottheimer, warned of increased traffic and pollution as drivers seek toll-free routes.
The Federal Highway Administration must address the court’s concerns by January 17, with both states responding by January 29. While New York pushes ahead, the program’s immediate future remains contested.
The New Jersey Digest is a new jersey magazine that has chronicled daily life in the Garden State for over 10 years.