Anesthesia awareness or intraoperative awareness is the term used to describe the distressing medical phenomenon where a patient gains consciousness mid-surgery while under general anesthesia. The patient may feel sensations of pressure, pain, overhear conversations, and recall the events in the operating room. The psychological impact of the event can be traumatic and lead to anxiety, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and depression.
The anesthetic techniques are put in place to prevent such incidents; however, failure in dosage, observation, or compliance with the procedure can cause anesthesia awareness and, in some cases, serve as grounds for a waking up during surgery lawsuit.
Such cases result from a breakdown of the standard of care in anesthesiology and may be due to negligence by the anesthesiologists or medical staff, like dosage miscalculation, failure to monitor anesthesia depth accurately, or use of defective equipment. Intraoperative awareness brought on by preventable errors constitutes medical malpractice and triggers liability.
What is Anesthesia Awareness
Anesthesia awareness is a state in which the patient under general anesthesia wakes up partially or fully in the middle of a surgical procedure. General anesthesia is administered to induce unconsciousness to prevent pain and prevent memory of the event. However, in some rare cases, in about 1 to 2 cases per 1,000 surgeries, a patient may wake up or gain awareness while under its effect and be unable to inform anybody of their state.
The degree of consciousness may vary. Some patients report vague sounds, details of the procedure, pain, anxiety, panic, or the inability to do anything due to the muscle relaxants hampering movement or speech. It can be traumatizing, leaving a lasting impact, as the patients may assume they are being hurt and are unable to alert anyone or protect themselves.
Common Causes of Anesthesia Awareness
Medical and technical issues may result in intraoperative awareness. The reason may be categorized into three categories: patient-specific risk factors, procedural choices, and medical errors.
1. Inadequate Dosage of Anesthetic Drugs
Insufficient anesthesia is one of the most direct causes resulting from an error in drug dosage calculation or a mechanical issue like an empty or blocked IV line. In cases where anesthetics dosage has to be lowered because of patient instability, such as low blood pressure, it is a known risk.
2. High-Risk Procedures
Some medical procedures have an increased risk of anesthesia awareness, such as trauma surgeries, emergency cesarean sections, and cardiac surgeries. These cases require continuing light anesthesia to preserve the patient’s vital functions.
3. Paralytic Agents Without Adequate Sedation
To prevent movements, muscle relaxants or paralytics are used. Administration of these drugs without adequate sedation or analgesia, the patient may remain conscious but unable to move. This drastically increases the chances of psychological trauma.
4. Faulty or Misused Monitoring Equipment
During anesthesia, brain activity, oxygen levels, and anesthetic concentration are monitored closely. Equipment malfunction or wrong interpretation of data can lead to misreading the level of the patient’s consciousness.
5. Inexperienced or Negligent Medical Staff
Human errors, such as in administering, managing, or adjusting anesthesia resulting from a lack of training or negligence, can also be contributory. Anesthesiologists are required to monitor the patient and respond to any signs that the anesthesia is ineffective.
Medical Malpractice and Legal Implications
Not all incidents of anesthesia awareness can be termed as malpractice. Courts examine if the standard of care was met and if the error could be avoided. Failure to follow guidelines like adjusting the dosage to match patient response or checking if the equipment was functioning may make an anesthesiologist liable.
The victims can claim damages for medical expenses, emotional suffering, therapy costs, and long-term psychological effects. To substantiate the claim, expert testimony, surgical records, and witness statements should be produced. Most patients cannot move during the event and are unable to inform staff. Therefore, post-operative interviews and early reporting of symptoms are important for documentation.
Psychological and Long-Term Effects
The psychological impact of anesthesia awareness can be as severe as the event. Individuals may suffer from nightmares, flashbacks, insomnia, anxiety disorders, or PTSD. Some studies have also shown that 50% of affected individuals suffer from long-term mental health consequences.
Recognizing and treating these psychological effects is as important as treating the physical causes. The condition is still misunderstood and dismissed by medical providers, which further complicates the individual’s recovery.
Prevention Strategies in Modern Anesthesia Practice
Modern anesthesia has incorporated several safety measures to minimize these incidents. These include:
- Depth of Anesthesia Monitors: Devices such as the bispectral index (BIS) measure brain activity to help determine the adequate sedation level.
- Vigilant Intraoperative Monitoring: Continuous monitoring of vital signs, anesthetic concentration, and patient response to reduce under-sedation.
- Patient Assessment: Identifying high-risk patients and adjusting anesthetic protocols as a key preventive measure.
- Post-Operative Debriefing: In the event of awareness or suspected awareness, immediate support, documentation, and mental health referrals can help mitigate trauma.
Although a rare occurrence, anesthesia awareness brings to the forefront the importance of thoroughness, patient safety protocols, and informed medical decision-making.
The New Jersey Digest is a new jersey magazine that has chronicled daily life in the Garden State for over 10 years.