We Finally Know New Jersey’s Favorite Thanksgiving Side. Next Door, New York Disagrees.

A Thanksgiving plate with stuffing, mashed potatoes and gravy, sliced turkey, roasted sweet potatoes, and broccoli rabe on a red plate

We Finally Know New Jersey’s Favorite Thanksgiving Side. Next Door, New York Disagrees.

A Thanksgiving plate with stuffing, mashed potatoes and gravy, sliced turkey, roasted sweet potatoes, and broccoli rabe on a red plate

Peter Candia

New Jersey Digest may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. As an Amazon Associate, New Jersey Digest earns from qualifying purchases.

Campbell’s new State of the Sides report found that stuffing is New Jersey’s favorite Thanksgiving side, while New York picked mac and cheese. The survey reached about 100 residents in each state.

Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and if you’re anything like me, then you care about the sides way more than the turkey. Listen, turkey is fine, but mashed potatoes? Stuffing? Candied sweet potatoes? Green beans? Those are the foods that keep me looking forward to Thanksgiving each year. 

A new State of the Sides report conducted by Campbell’s looked to identify the most popular Thanksgiving side in each state. In New Jersey, stuffing reigns supreme. 

This makes sense to me. Stuffing is easily my favorite side on the table, and it usually carries a ton of tradition with it. Anecdotally, my mother’s stuffing—made with ground pork sausage, dried bread, celery, and some other goodies—will always be my favorite. It’s one of those dishes that usually comes with a passed-down recipe, and that’s what Thanksgiving is all about. 

But anecdotes only get you so far. How exactly did Campbell’s determine the winner? 

How Campbell’s Picked the Winner

New Jersey isn’t alone. Stuffing (sometimes called dressing in certain regions) dominates the list—it’s the most popular side in 39 states, counting a tie in Utah. To determine each state’s most popular side dish, Campbell’s commissioned a survey of 5,017 U.S. residents who celebrate Thanksgiving. At least 100 people were surveyed in each of the 50 states. 

Stuffing is the common denominator across the nation, but especially in the Northeast, where every state except for New York pledged their allegiance to the bready side. New York chose mac and cheese. 

Other sides recognized are mashed potatoes in California, Nebraska, Kansas, Iowa, Indiana, and West Virginia; mac and cheese in Texas, New York, Georgia, and North Carolina; and yams in Louisiana.

The Sides Are Winning

In addition to a survey of which sides, the report also outlined some interesting pieces of data. I’m apparently not alone in my love for the sides over the turkey—four out of five Americans say they enjoy cooking the sides more than turkey. Nearly half of Americans (46%) would be fine with no turkey at all. I wasn’t surveyed, but you can add my name to the list. 

And the love for sides is growing. Some 86% of Americans serve four or more sides on the table—that’s a 16% increase since 2023. Additionally, 76% say family recipes passed down to them carry extra significance, 56% of Americans enjoy sides that reflect their culture or region, and 88% say they genuinely enjoy traditional Thanksgiving sides, choosing them out of legitimate preference and not just for the routine of it. 

As for me and my family, we keep Thanksgiving “Jersey-classic.” That means the usuals of stuffing and mashed potatoes, along with baked ziti and cold antipasto—maybe some broccoli rabe too. Not sorry. 

Peter Candia is the Food + Drink Editor at New Jersey Digest. A graduate of The Culinary Institute of America, Peter found a passion for writing midway through school and never looked back. He is a former line cook, server and bartender at top-rated restaurants in the tri-state area. In addition to food, Peter enjoys politics, music, sports and anything New Jersey.