If you’re planning a Caribbean getaway but want to make sure safety is a priority, you’re not alone. With hurricane season approaching and travel advisories shifting each year, many travelers are seeking destinations where they can truly relax without worry. According to the newly released Caribbean Island Safety Index 2025, these five islands stand out as the safest for visitors, with Aruba earning the top spot.
1. Aruba — Safety Score: 9.3
Aruba has built its reputation not only on sunshine and turquoise waters but also on peace of mind. With one of the lowest crime rates in the region and a Level 1 U.S. travel advisory, Aruba ranked a perfect 10 out of 10 for both overall safety and hurricane risk.
The island sits outside the hurricane belt, giving travelers more confidence when booking summer or fall trips. Aruba also benefits from Dutch-influenced healthcare standards, earning it an 8 out of 10 for medical access. Add in Arikok National Park, its desert-meets-coastline landscapes, and year-round festivals, and it’s easy to see why Aruba leads the list.
2. Barbados — Safety Score: 9.2
Though just 20 miles long, Barbados packs a big punch for travelers. Known for its friendly locals, vibrant culture, and fresh island cuisine, this eastern Caribbean nation combines natural beauty with everyday convenience.
Barbados currently holds a Level 1 U.S. travel advisory, meaning visitors can travel with confidence while simply exercising normal precautions. From exploring Harrison’s Cave to dining in Bridgetown, travelers will find the island welcoming and easy to navigate.
3. Grenada — Safety Score: 9.0
Grenada, often called the “Spice Isle,” offers the kind of laid-back charm that makes visitors feel at home. With low violent crime rates and a stable political climate, it consistently ranks among the safest islands for international travel.
Nature lovers flock to Grand Anse Beach, a two-mile stretch of soft sand and calm waters perfect for a day in the sun. Beyond the beach, Grenada’s spice markets, waterfalls, and hiking trails showcase the island’s authenticity and warmth.
3 (TIE). Curaçao — Safety Score: 9.0
Sharing cultural ties with Aruba and Bonaire, Curaçao is the largest of the three “ABC Islands.” Located just 40 miles north of Venezuela, it’s one of the Caribbean’s most colorful escapes, with iconic Dutch-style architecture and a lively harbor scene.
Travelers often find Curaçao surprisingly affordable, thanks to frequent flight deals. Like its neighbors, it sits outside the main hurricane belt, offering a reliable option for late summer and fall vacations.
5. Antigua & Barbuda — Safety Score: 8.1
With 365 beaches, quite literally one for every day of the year, Antigua and Barbuda is a dream destination for anyone seeking variety. Beyond the sandy shores, travelers can explore lush rainforests, mangroves, and the buzzing capital city of St. John’s.
The island’s food scene, highlighted by fresh seafood and casual rum bars, adds to its charm. Visitors looking for a sunset cocktail often head to Sheer Rocks, one of Antigua’s most scenic dining spots.
Why Safety Matters in the Caribbean
While many Caribbean destinations are postcard-worthy, not all have the same safety rankings. Islands such as Haiti currently carry higher U.S. travel advisories due to crime, unrest, or limited access to healthcare. That’s why choosing islands with consistently high safety scores can make all the difference for a worry-free vacation.
Whether you’re craving an eco-adventure in Aruba, a cultural escape in Barbados, or endless beaches in Antigua, these five islands prove that safety and paradise can go hand in hand.
The New Jersey Digest is a new jersey magazine that has chronicled daily life in the Garden State for over 10 years.